How House2Play helps · Step 2
Step 2: Find the House
A great vacation rental starts with buying the right property.
The house needs to work for your family, but it also needs to make sense as a rental.
That means looking beyond the listing photos and asking questions about location, regulations, accessibility, guest capacity, operating costs, and revenue potential before you make an offer.
These are some of the questions we’ll work through together while searching for your property.
Eight lenses on the same house
- 01 Personal fit
- 02 Location and accessibility
- 03 Rental legality
- 04 Market performance
- 05 Operating costs
- 06 Guest capacity
- 07 Parking
- 08 Revenue-driving amenities
Personal fit
What is your budget?
Your purchase price is only part of the equation.
We’ll look at how much you want to invest, how much cash you want to put into the property after closing, and what level of rental performance makes the purchase worthwhile.
A less expensive house is not always the better investment if it requires significant renovations, has lower rental demand, or lacks the features guests are willing to pay for.
Location and accessibility
What part of town should you buy in?
Location matters, but the best vacation rental location is not always the same neighborhood you would choose for a traditional home.
Consider:
- Proximity to the attractions bringing guests to the market
- Restaurants, shopping, marinas, beaches, entertainment, or other demand drivers
- Neighborhood quality and guest appeal
- Travel time from the property’s likely feeder markets
- Whether guests can easily understand and navigate the location
Sometimes being five minutes closer to an attraction can materially change booking demand. In other markets, privacy, views, waterfront access, or acreage may matter more.
Location and accessibility
Is the property easy to access?
Guests are only part of the equation.
Your cleaner, maintenance providers, contractors, delivery drivers, and property manager also need reliable access to the home.
Consider:
- Road conditions
- Steep or difficult driveways
- Seasonal access
- Stairs and entry points
- Distance from local service providers
- Ease of getting supplies, furniture, appliances, and equipment to the property
A beautiful house can become difficult and expensive to operate if every service call becomes a logistical challenge.
Rental legality
Are short-term rentals allowed?
This is one of the first questions that should be answered before getting serious about a property.
Rental rules can exist at several levels, including:
- City or county regulations
- Zoning restrictions
- Licensing requirements
- Occupancy limits
- Parking requirements
- HOA or condominium association rules
The fact that other vacation rentals exist nearby does not automatically mean a new owner can legally operate one.
We’ll help identify the applicable restrictions before you move too far into the purchase process.
House2Play is not a law firm and none of this is legal advice. Rules change often and vary by address, so we confirm the current requirements with the city, county and association during the search, and we recommend your own attorney review anything that decides the purchase.
Market performance
Does this property type perform well in the market?
Not every type of property performs equally.
A condo may be a great investment in one vacation market and significantly underperform a single-family home in another.
We’ll compare the property to actual rental demand in the market, including:
- Property type
- Bedroom count
- Guest capacity
- Location
- Amenities
- Seasonality
- Comparable vacation rentals
The goal is not simply to find a house you like. It is to understand how that type of property competes for bookings.
Operating costs
What are the HOA costs and rental restrictions?
An HOA can provide valuable amenities and maintenance, but it can also change the economics of the property.
Evaluate:
- Monthly or annual HOA dues
- Special assessments
- Short-term rental restrictions
- Minimum rental periods
- Guest registration requirements
- Parking rules
- Amenity access
- Property management restrictions
A property with strong rental revenue can still become a poor investment if operating expenses are too high or the association limits how it can be rented.
Guest capacity
How many bedrooms do you need?
Bedroom count matters for both your family and your future guests.
Consider how many bedrooms the owner personally needs while also looking at how bedroom count affects:
- Nightly rate
- Occupancy
- Guest capacity
- Cleaning cost
- Purchase price
- Revenue potential
More bedrooms can produce more revenue, but they usually come with a higher purchase price and additional operating expenses.
The objective is to find the point where the additional revenue justifies the additional investment.
Parking
Is there enough parking?
Parking is easy to overlook during a showing, but it becomes extremely important once guests arrive.
A property that sleeps twelve people may realistically need parking for four or five vehicles.
Consider:
- Number of usable parking spaces
- Garage availability
- Trailer or boat parking
- HOA parking restrictions
- Street parking rules
- Driveway layout
Guest capacity should make sense not just inside the house, but outside it as well.
Revenue-driving amenities
Is there space for revenue-driving amenities?
Amenities can dramatically change how a vacation rental competes.
Look for indoor and outdoor spaces that could support features such as:
- Hot tubs
- Fire pits
- Game rooms
- Outdoor kitchens
- Pools
- Saunas
- Theater rooms
- Putting greens
- Boat docks
- Gathering spaces
- Children’s play areas
The question is not simply:
“What amenities can we add?”
It is:
“Which amenities will guests in this market actually pay more for?”
A property with the right spaces can create opportunities to increase nightly rates, improve occupancy, and separate the listing from competing homes.
Finding the right property
There is no single formula for the perfect vacation rental.
Some properties win because of location. Others win because of views, amenities, guest capacity, waterfront access, or an unusual feature competitors cannot easily duplicate.
Throughout the search, evaluate each property from two perspectives:
Would you and your family enjoy owning it?
Can we build a vacation rental around it that makes financial sense?
The right property needs to answer yes to both.
Know the numbers before you offer
Our free profit calculator models purchase price, financing, nightly rate, occupancy and every operating cost, then shows what a property actually returns. It is the same tool we use on our own deals.
Found the right house? Step 3 is making it earn.
Once a property is under contract the work turns to design: the layout, the furnishings and the amenities that guests in that market actually book. Bring us a listing you are considering and we will tell you what we would do with it.
Want to see one of ours in action? Book a stay at The Hideout.
