top of page

How House2Play helps · Step 1

Step 1: Selecting Your Market

Every other decision follows this one. Here is how I would make it.

What market should you choose for your vacation rental?

You can watch an endless amount of YouTube videos and social media content telling you where the “best” vacation rental markets are.

My advice is simpler.

Start with the places you and your family actually enjoy.

Not the market with the highest average nightly rate. Not necessarily the market closest to your house. Start with the places where you would genuinely want to own a vacation home, spend weekends, take your kids, and make memories.

Then we determine whether buying there makes financial sense.

“But it’s too far away.”

One of the most common objections I hear from potential buyers is:

“It’s too far away. What happens if something goes wrong?”

My response is always:

What exactly are you planning to drive there to fix?

  • If there’s a plumbing problem, are you going to repair it yourself?
  • If something breaks, are you bringing your own tools?
  • If the house is missing towels, are you going to drive several hours to deliver them?

I’ve been hosting vacation rentals for five years, and I have yet to encounter a problem that required me to jump in the car and personally save the day.

Most problems are solved with a phone call or a message to a cleaner, handyman, plumber, HVAC technician, electrician, or other local service provider. Sometimes the solution is as simple as an Amazon order delivered directly to the property.

The goal isn’t to be close enough to personally handle every problem.

The goal is to build a local team so you don’t have to.

That doesn’t mean distance should never matter. A market with poor contractor availability, limited cleaning services, difficult winter access, or other operational challenges deserves additional consideration.

But I would not eliminate a market simply because it is a few hours from home.

Start with where you want to be. Then validate it.

Once we’ve identified markets you would actually enjoy owning in, we start treating the decision like an investment.

We look at:

  • Vacation rental demand and seasonality
  • Typical nightly rates and occupancy
  • Purchase prices and financing
  • Short-term rental laws and licensing
  • Taxes and insurance
  • Availability and cost of cleaners and contractors
  • Competition and existing rental inventory
  • The types of properties and amenities guests are actually booking
  • Your expected personal use of the property
  • Projected revenue, expenses, and cash flow

Some markets you love won’t survive that analysis. That’s okay.

The objective isn’t to force a vacation rental to work anywhere you want to vacation. It’s to find the overlap between a place your family loves and a property that makes financial sense.

That’s where I like to start.

Where does your family want to make memories?

Don’t begin your search by asking:

“What’s the hottest Airbnb market right now?”

Start by asking:

“Where would we be excited to own a vacation home?”

Then let’s find out whether there’s a great investment hiding there.

Know the numbers before you offer

Our free profit calculator models purchase price, financing, nightly rate, occupancy and every operating cost, then shows what a property actually returns. It is the same tool we use on our own deals.

Cash flowCap rateCash-on-cashPayback year

Found a market you love? Now let’s find the right property.

Step 2 is the search itself: budget, location, access, rental rules, guest capacity, parking and the amenities guests in that market will pay for. Bring a property or bring a shortlist, and we will run the numbers on the ones worth an offer.

Want to see one of ours in action? Book a stay at The Hideout.

bottom of page